|

Can Germany keep up in systems engineering?

Industry in Germany

Turnover of German and American groupsGermany is worried: Digital Agenda, Industry 4.0 - all the buzzwords are buzzing around, but will Germany be able to keep up with the rapid pace of development? While Google, Apple and Tessla are developing new cars, VW is grappling with the emissions scandal. While Tessla relies on open source, German board members are worried that their knowledge could be stolen. And things are not looking good financially either: Apple and Google want to build cars, and both are more than five times the size of Daimler - that should give us pause for thought. (from: The Economist, Does Germany do Digital?November 21, 2015).

The New Responsibility Foundation tries to reassure and argues that network effects in manufacturing are smaller than in the digital sector, as these markets move more slowly and are more complex. Expertise is not easy to replicate and the data generated by products is easier to control. But the Economist in the article cited above thinks this is an illusion:

„First: Platforms are only successful if they are also used by other companies, developers and customers.
Secondly: Successful platforms are usually open. Even if some manufacturers in Germany claim to be open, their behavior is rather hesitant.
Thirdly: Central to platforms is the exchange of data, which is neither in the nature of German companies nor easily compatible with the strict German data protection laws.
Fourthly: The culture in German companies is still hierarchical. Although there are attempts to give teams more autonomy or set up internal incubators, this is often little more than lip service.

Nevertheless - Germany has a hell of a lot to offer, and I can imagine that in the medium term the care and precision of German companies will be a major competitive advantage (if we can maintain it). Unfortunately, with many modern products (such as cell phones, for example), you get the feeling that the customer is being abused as a beta tester for products that are not fully developed.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply